Sunday, July 2, 2017

OBSERVATION AT CIRCULO INFANTIL: LEARNING EVALUATION

     As Learning Evaluation requires more than theory we visited a school with an active model. The school was Circulo Infantil BUAP. In this ocassion we could obrserve the English class of teacher Liliana with a third grade group of children.

The whole experience was very interesting because we went there expecting different things from what we saw there. The English class just lasted 30 min. and teacher Liliana covers a topic during the whole week. That time they were reviewing vocabulary of animals. Teacher Liliana planned a game, but before that, she introduces us to students. Inmediately a girl asked for permission to introduce herself and the others did it too. We were imppresed about the motivation and good attitude that students have to participate. After this, teacher Liliana asked them to mention a day of the week, a month an to count how many students went to class that day. Then they played a game and the teacher asked us to get involve with students helping them to wear the cards' support and listen at what they had to tell us.
At the end of the class we interviewed the teacher and ask her about the system of evaluation, she told us that students do not have a formal evaluation from her. The titular teachers (who are more in contact with students) have a portfolio for each student and a binnacle of what are the strenghts and weaknesses of each student as well as the development in class and all the thing they are able to do. My conclusion to this is that they practice a formative evaluation, because they focus on the process of students' learning more than in grades.
We also asked teacher Liliana about the way she evaluates students in class, she said that she evaluates them according to their participation and for instance, motivation, the level of integration and the attitudes toward the class. Also, she told us that it is important to take into account students' feelings so, they do not have to be obligated to work if they do not want to. However, all this bad attitudes are included in the binnacle so parents do something about it.
We evaluated the exposure to language and my conclusion is that they are not exposed to it enough, because the teacher gave them instructions in spanish. Students of this groups have an excelent level of memory, I think if they were exposed to the language with more frequency, then they could learn more than vocabulary.
Experience:
My experience doing this was very nice, because I never saw how this type of schol work with their students. I was really happy to be with them and get involve in their daily life. Before this I was sure I wanted to teach English to children, now I am completely sure about it.

EVALUATION INTERVIEW.


     In order to know the perception about what it has been reviewed during this course, I interviewed a teacher who is involved in the area of evaluation. The topics reviewed in the interview with the teacher Jacobo are the following:
-Advantages and Drawbacks of Summantive and Formative Assessment.
-Homework, c-maps, portfolios and rubrics as assessment tools and the mexican perception about homework.
-Tests as the unique way of assessing students’ knowledge.
-Basis for developing tests.
-Common errors of teachers when developing a test.
-Way of evaluation in Mexico compared with Finland.

This is the interview.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbTx4FofoAg


Experience:
For me it was very interesting to talk about evaluation with an expert in the topic because I could understand what is the conception about the ones that design tests. It was also challenging because I was very nervous, however I calmed down when I noticed he was also nervous. The only negative point in this experience is that the teacher did not allow me to record, so I got just his voice. I think this is something to consider if this activity is going to be used in students in the future, because as well as many teachers have any problema with being recorded, there are others that do not like it.

SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT: TESTING

     The typical way to assess students that teachers and students know the most is testing. Tests have the purpose of identifying students’ strenghts and weakneasses in order to work further on them, however, there are other types of tests that accomplish other objectives and what teachers need to know about students learning or abilities.
     In the following map it is explained the types of tests that exist as well as the purpose of using them. Also, after this, you will find an explanation about the elements that good tests must accomplish and principles to design them.



Placement test:
     This types of tests are a requirement for some institutions in order to create an homogenious group with students of the same level of language ability. In other words, placement test assess students’ level of language ability in order to place them in the correct group, course or class.
Aptitude Tests:
     This tests masure the capacity or general ability of students to learn a foreign language. This type of tests are used for deciding to enroll them in a special training because of their language aptitudes.
Diagnostic Tests:
     Do you remember this mexican common phrase used by teachers at the beggining of a course?: “Solamente para saber cómo vienen”. Well, this phrase was herad because our teachers were about to apply a diagnostic test. This type of tests have the purpose to identify the areas of the language in which students need further helps than in others. It is important to highlight that there tests are base don failure, because the áreas that students fail are the áreas which need more attention.
Progress Tests:
     Progress tests are intended to measure the progress of students in a defined course. These help teachers to know at what extent students are learning what is being reviewed in a course and, if there is poor learning then, have the chance to remediate it.
Achievement tests:
     These tests have the purpose of determining what a student has learned with regarding during the first half of the course of at the end.
Proficiency tests:
     This type of tests assess the overall language ability of students in different levels. Thus, proficiency tests help instructors and learners to know what the learner can do with the language in the different skills.
Objective Tests:
     Objective tests are the ones that are scored by comparing students’ responses with a pre-established set of “correct” responses. For instance, the scorers do not require particular knowledge in the area.
Subjective Tests:
     This type of tests requires scoring being base don opinión or personal judgement, then, the scorers need particular knowledge in the area is being tested. A clear example of this is writing essays.
Criterion- Referenced Tests: 
     This tests are intended to measure the mastery of students’ learning. This type of testing should be based on clear objectives and the scores are compared with the quatity of given material during the taken period of time.
Standardized Tests: 
     Standardized tests have the purpose of measuring the global language ability to students. The way of scoring is based on the comparison of results with the other students’ (who also took the tests) results.
High-Stakes Tests:
     This type of tests are the ones that their results are likely to have an important impact on an individuals’ life. That is tos ay, that the results can be the “Yes” for acquiring a scholarship or ti getting a new job.
Low-Stakes Tests:
     On the contrary to high-stakes tests, these have a lower impact in the individual’s life. For example, quizzes.}

     In order to develop tests it is important to take into account some elements in order to get a clear, effective and not tedious test:
Purpose: The creation of a test should be base don the purpose it has to be accomplished and, in this way, select the correct type of test according to what is needed.
Timing: This refers to the correct time for applying tests. It is important to know that a progress test cannot be applied at the end of the course.
Now, the design of a test should be based on these principles:
Usefulness: Bachman and Palmer (1996) claim that the use of tests is the most important thing to take in consideration because avery test should have a specific purpose.
Validity: This term refers to the extent at ehich a test measures the purpose of it. There are three types of validity: the first is content validity; it means that the test assesses the course content, or what it was reviewed during the course. Construct validity makes reference to the relationship between the theory and the methodology of language learning as well as the type of assessment. Then, face validity means that a test shoud measure what it is supposed to, because of this, it is importan to have a clear perception about that is wanted to be assessed.
Reliability: It has to be with the consistency of test scores. In other words: if the same test is applyed in different times, to different groups in different settings the results or scores should be the similar.
There are three factors that affect reliability: formats, content of the questions and time.
Practicality: This terms refers to the usefulness that a test may have in different situations.
Washback: This refers to the effect that testing may have on teaching and learning. Can be positive if students and teachers have common knowledge for the test or know the same things about the test. Washback can also be negative if for example, students just know what they have to know to pass the exam.
Authenticity: This has to be with the level of real-life situations that a test may contain, so students find useful learning what they are supposed to according to the syllabus.
Transparency: This has to be with the accurate and clear information that tests should contain.
Security: This principle has to be with the decision of letting self-designed test in the public domain or not.
Experience:
     Developing this map I realized that there are some elements that I was not taking into consideration when I developed my own test for an activity. There are many elements that make a good test dor teachers and for students. I related this principles with some experiences I had, so I think this activity was meaningful. The only thing that I found difficult was to paraphrase the meaning of each element and principles, however I think that most of readers may understand what each one means with a short and clear definition.

ASSESSMENT TOOLS: C-MAPS, RUBRICS & PORTFOLIOS; VIDEO


     In order to accomplish any type of assessment teachers should make use of resources to reinforce their way of teaching and, for instance, the way of evaluating. For this reason, in this entry it is found an explanation about three assessment tools commonly used in formative assessment. Those tools are c-maps, rubrics and portfolios that have different purposes when are used in the classroom and that the result depends on the way teachers apply them and the objective they have to accomplish at the end of the class.
     In the following video I am talking about what each assessment tool is, the purpose of teachers to use them and the specific point in which they work as effective assessment tools.




Experience:
     I feel very happy about this video because, even though the information seem to be easy to understand it was difficult to me to keep it simple and do not give useless information. When I finished of recording the 17th video and I watched it I felt very satisfied because everything I said was clear for me and I do not have too many hesitations like in my previous videos. Honestly, before this, I preferred oral presentations because I though this was just taking my time, however practicing what I should say and keep it simple as I already mention, help me to improve in my conception of ideas and how to express them.

ASSESSMENT TOOLS: C-MAPS, RUBRICS & PORTFOLIOS

     In order to accomplish any type of assessment teachers should make use of resources to reinforce their way of teaching and, for instance, the way of evaluating. For this reason, in this entry it is found an explanation about three assessment tools commonly used in formative assessment. Those tools are c-maps, rubrics and portfolios that have different purposes when are used in the classroom and that the result dependo n the way teachers apply them and the objective they have to accomplish at the end of the class.
In the following map you will find three assessmento tools as well as their definition, and the advantages of using them as assessment.



     There are two types of assessment which are formative and summative.  In the formative assessment teachers focus their attention on the student’s process of learning rather than in grades (which is the summative assessment). For this, teachers may use assessment tools like Concept maps, portfolios and rubrics, although the last one depends ond the purpose teachers have as well as the way in which they apply rubrics, in order to be of the type of formative or summative.
     The first tool are concept maps. These are visual and graphic presentations intended to organize knowledge, clarify and explicate ideas. This method is usefull because it helps students to construct, organize and communicate knowledge.
     For developing a concept map, this has to have some elements: the first are nodes which represent concepts. concept maps also need links that represent the relationship between a concept and another, and finally, link phrases which specify the type of relationship between concepts. These elements can vary according to the type of concept map that is wanted to be developed.
     Now, how can a c- map be an assessment tool? Well, when developing c-maps students have to make use of metacognitive skills like organizing, and analyzing data, correlating appropiate information and synthetizing ideas in order to create meaning. In this way, teachers can assess what students have learned or not. Remember the congnitive theory? This theory says that language is a reflection of what is on an individual’s mind, then concept maps are a reflection of what is on students’ mind. For instance, lacks of knowledge missunderstandings or missconceptions are exposed with this method. 
     The next assessment tool are rubrics. Rubrics are a written outsteps and procedures to follow assigments based on expectations that teachers have from students. Rubrics contain all the information about the aspects of quality that an assigment or performance should accomplish. Thus, rubrics describe levels of quality from what is proficient and what is poor. In other words, a rubric describes the criteria for performance in different levels which the teacher has to score according to what it is considered as acceptable.
     Besides, there are two types of rubrics: Holistic and Analytic. Holistic rubrics help instructors to score an overall project or presentation as a whole. This type of rubrics are suitabe for projects which have no easy division into smaller pieces and it is less time consuming. 
     On the other hand, analytic rubrics are the ones that focus on specific parts of a Project. In other words, analytic rubris break projects into their individual parts in order to rate them using a scale. 
     Finally, we have portfolios that are collections of individual work from students’ performance, thus, portfolios are a collection of evidence about the growth of students over a period of time. This assessment tool is commonly used to support instruction which emphasizes students’ participation, understanding and engagement. 
     All the mentioned assessment tools are helpful to gather information about student’ development during a period of time. However, rubrics depend on the purpose and how teachers use them, because those can be of the type of summative assessment if they don’t go together with feedback. Then, if we want to make stronger our formative assessment we can use these tools in order to help students to get higher levels of learning and prepare them better for the next step.
Experience: 
In developing this map I understood that all types of assessmet require some help in order to make learning simple and easy to understand ore ven just to use other new and creative ways of documenting students’ growth in their school years. I feel very satisfied because I could understand this topic (more tan the other ones) very well. However I still learning how softwares for developing maps work.

SUMMATIVE AND FORMATIVE ASSESSMENTS: VIDEO

     In order to measure students’ learning results and process of learning teacher may make use of two types of assessment: Summative or Formative depending on what they want to focus in order to assess students.
     In the following video I explain what each type of assessment is intended to, the purpose of using them the advantages and drawbacks as well as a similarity that results very important to me.




Experience:
Recording this video I faced some problems because I didin’t understand the information easily, however at the time of writing down my ideas about what I had tos ay everything started to make sense. I were able to relate it to some of the experiences I have had in my school years and make me thing critically about what type of teacher I want to be. I feel proud of this video because I didn’t record it in different clips. I explained everything and just cut off when I take too much time to start talking. Something I want to add is that in a part I said Summative assessment instead of formative. I noticed it when I saw it at the end.

SUMMATIVE AND FORMATIVE ASSESSMENTS


     In order to measure students’ learning results and process of learning teacher may make use of two types of assessment: Summative or Formative.
     In the following map it is explained what the goals, similarities and differences are between summative and formative assessment.



     Summative assessment is based on the typical grades and scores that teacher use to summarize what students’ learning during a period of time, for example, a term or a course. Moreover, teachers use this kind of assessment in order to get a measure about how well a student did during the selected period of time.
     One of the advantages of summative assessment is that it creates a sense of responsability on students (at some extent) because the grades can be seen by parents and this creates a symptom of presure on them, more tan in young students rather than in older. Besides, summative assessment is base don tasks assigned by teachers so, in order to pass with good grades, students have to deliver those tasks and, for instance, practice or reviewing the clases and intructions, even when some students just copy other Works. With the above I do not mean that it is correct but, at the time of doing this, students have to, at least, read and change some phrases, so they cannot scape from reviewing.
     One important drawback about summative assessment is that once that teachers get scores of students there is no chance to go back and remediate what they did wrong or to repair learning deficiencies.
     Another negative point of this type of assessment is that getting a good grade or score does not take for granted that students are learning.
     On the other hand, there is formative assessment whicn is intended to provide information about the process that students have to pass through to learn. That means that it is part of instruction which is opposite to the formative assessment which comes at the end of the instruction.
     The most important element in formative assessment is feedback, that, from my point of view, should be considered as an assessment tool because it helps students to improve their quality of understanding.
     One of the advantages of this type of assessment is that it reveals learning gaps and developmental delays. A clear example of formative assessment are oral presentations because with this, teachers can observe what things are not clear for the student and then, coreect them.
     Also, on the contrary to summative assessment, students can get feedback and correct what is wrong on time, in this way, the possibilities to get better scores increase for students.
     Other positive point for this way of assessing students is that they are in constant improvement until students reach the level the teacher expects from them.
     The only drawback that I consider is that formative assessment is time consuming because the explanations and clarifuing doubts to students can take a loto f time.
     Remember that at the beggining of this entry it was mentioned that summative is base don typical grades? That is because most of teachers need to report those numbers to principals and parents, so their job is only to give a grade and then go back home happy because the course or the term has finished. However every teacher has to remind his/herself that grades do not reflect knowledge. Instead of doing this, they have to take into account one similarity between the two types of assessment already mentioned (that I consider a RULE): Both types of assessment have to work together in order to give principals, bosses and parents what they want (Scores) but give students what they need (Learning) in order to prepare them better for the next level and make grades significant and filled with something more than air.
Experience:
With the elaboration of this map I understood the key to assess the real knowledge of students. At the beggining I had a lot of doubts about summative assessment and a negative perception of this, however, when I thought about this deeply I realized that it is not something incorrectly but is incorrectly done.