In order to measure students’ learning results and process of
learning teacher may make use of two types of assessment: Summative or
Formative.
In the following map it is explained what the goals, similarities and differences are between summative and formative assessment.
Summative assessment is based on the typical grades and
scores that teacher use to summarize what students’ learning during a period of
time, for example, a term or a course. Moreover, teachers use this kind of
assessment in order to get a measure about how well a student did during the
selected period of time.
One of the advantages of summative assessment is that it
creates a sense of responsability on students (at some extent) because the
grades can be seen by parents and this creates a symptom of presure on them,
more tan in young students rather than in older. Besides, summative assessment
is base don tasks assigned by teachers so, in order to pass with good grades,
students have to deliver those tasks and, for instance, practice or reviewing
the clases and intructions, even when some students just copy other Works. With
the above I do not mean that it is correct but, at the time of doing this,
students have to, at least, read and change some phrases, so they cannot scape
from reviewing.
One important drawback about summative assessment is that once
that teachers get scores of students there is no chance to go back and
remediate what they did wrong or to repair learning deficiencies.
Another negative point of this type of assessment is that
getting a good grade or score does not take for granted that students are
learning.
On the other hand, there is formative assessment whicn is
intended to provide information about the process that students have to pass
through to learn. That means that it is part of instruction which is opposite
to the formative assessment which comes at the end of the instruction.
The most important element in formative assessment is
feedback, that, from my point of view, should be considered as an assessment
tool because it helps students to improve their quality of understanding.
One of the advantages of this type of assessment is that it reveals
learning gaps and developmental delays. A clear example of formative assessment
are oral presentations because with this, teachers can observe what things are
not clear for the student and then, coreect them.
Also, on the contrary to summative assessment, students can
get feedback and correct what is wrong on time, in this way, the possibilities
to get better scores increase for students.
Other positive point for this way of assessing students is
that they are in constant improvement until students reach the level the
teacher expects from them.
The only drawback that I consider is that formative
assessment is time consuming because the explanations and clarifuing doubts to
students can take a loto f time.
Remember that at the beggining of this entry it was mentioned
that summative is base don typical grades? That is because most of teachers
need to report those numbers to principals and parents, so their job is only to
give a grade and then go back home happy because the course or the term has
finished. However every teacher has to remind his/herself that grades do not
reflect knowledge. Instead of doing this, they have to take into account one
similarity between the two types of assessment already mentioned (that I
consider a RULE): Both types of assessment have to work together in order to
give principals, bosses and parents what they want (Scores) but give students
what they need (Learning) in order to prepare them better for the next level
and make grades significant and filled with something more than air.
Experience:
With
the elaboration of this map I understood the key to assess the real knowledge
of students. At the beggining I had a lot of doubts about summative assessment
and a negative perception of this, however, when I thought about this deeply I
realized that it is not something incorrectly but is incorrectly done.
No comments:
Post a Comment